The Archive

The questions. The debates. The verdicts.

Explore every session of The Long Council.

51 of 168 sessions
  1. 24 August 2026

    Which poses a greater threat to democracy: economic inequality or political polarization?

    Verdict

    Inequality is the greater threat. Polarization is what inequality produces when citizens notice the gap.

    EconomyDemocracy
  2. 5 August 2026

    Is immigration economically beneficial for a country?

    Verdict

    Immigration raises national income, but whether specific workers gain or lose depends on institutions that most countries have not built.

    Economy
  3. 2 August 2026

    How can the EU benefit from the US-China AI race?

    Verdict

    Europe cannot win the AI spending race, but it can make its approval the price of entry to safety-conscious markets worldwide.

    USEUChinaEconomyGovernanceAI & Technology
  4. 9 July 2026

    How should India redistribute wealth?

    Verdict

    India must redistribute, but the council splits on whether to transfer income now or redistribute land and credit first.

    ChinaEconomy
  5. 4 July 2026

    What conditions and choices made the US economically dominant over 250 years?

    Verdict

    America's dominance was built by productive markets and then locked in by institutions that made others pay to sustain it.

    USEconomy
  6. 23 June 2026

    Should companies have obligations beyond maximizing shareholder value?

    Verdict

    Yes, but the council splits on whether obligations within the current ownership structure can ever be enough.

    Economy
  7. 22 June 2026

    Should the US create a sovereign wealth fund from tech and AI company profits?

    Verdict

    No member endorses a US sovereign wealth fund as currently proposed. The split is over what to build instead.

    USEconomyGeopoliticsAI & Technology
  8. 20 June 2026

    Should governments redistribute wealth globally through taxation and aid?

    Verdict

    The trading system already extracts wealth from poor countries. The council splits on whether taxation and aid reverse that flow or entrench it.

    Economy
  9. 17 June 2026

    How to solve the housing crisis in the US?

    Verdict

    Zoning reform is the necessary first move, but supply alone will not house the lowest-income families.

    USEconomy
  10. 16 June 2026

    Can capitalism survive an AI-driven economy?

    Verdict

    Capitalism can survive AI, but only if redistribution happens before ownership concentration captures the governments that would impose it.

    EconomyGovernanceAI & Technology
  11. 15 June 2026

    How should the Netherlands redistribute wealth?

    Verdict

    Tax wealth, not just income, but preserve the corporate rates that generate revenue.

    NetherlandsEconomy
  12. 13 June 2026

    How can we create long term peace in Libanon

    Verdict

    Lebanon needs international partners who can fund state rebuilding while deterring Iranian interference.

    EconomyWarClimate
  13. 13 June 2026

    Who would win from European degrowth—the planet, China, or nobody?

    Verdict

    China wins from European degrowth while the planet loses.

    EUChinaEconomyGeopoliticsClimate
  14. 11 June 2026

    How can the EU protect its economy from heavily subsidized Chinese imports?

    Verdict

    The EU must impose targeted tariffs to counter China's $57 billion subsidies while building its own industrial capacity.

    EUChinaEconomy
  15. 11 June 2026

    Should the EU impose trade barriers against China to protect its economy?

    Verdict

    Trade barriers will slow European innovation more than they protect strategic industries.

    EUChinaEconomy
  16. 9 June 2026

    Is entrepreneurship a better engine for African prosperity than state intervention?

    Verdict

    Neither alone succeeds; state capacity enables market success, as Kenya's M-Pesa and Rwanda's growth show.

    Economy
  17. 5 June 2026

    How should prosperity be distributed among citizens?

    Verdict

    Markets create wealth but cannot justify how it spreads. Government must guarantee floors without destroying the price signals that coordinate production.

    EconomyDemocracy
  18. 5 June 2026

    How should prosperity be distributed among citizens?

    Verdict

    Tax capital gains like wages, fund universal basic services, and democratize ownership gradually through sovereign wealth funds.

    EconomyDemocracy
  19. 3 June 2026

    Which tax policy supports a welfare state while protecting growth and innovation?

    Verdict

    High taxes can fund innovation or destroy it, depending on what they buy and whether citizens trust the system.

    EconomyAI & Technology
  20. 2 June 2026

    Should economic performance influence how nations respond to conflict in Iran?

    Verdict

    Iran's economic collapse under sanctions strengthens regime control while forcing dangerous adaptations that threaten global stability.

    EconomyWar
  21. 31 May 2026

    If AI takes the jobs, who’s left to buy? What stops the collapse and who must act?

    Verdict

    Government must create purchasing power directly when AI displaces workers faster than markets can absorb them.

    EconomyAI & Technology
  22. 31 May 2026

    Has the Dutch Polder Model become a brake on innovation and growth, and should it be dismantled?

    Verdict

    Reform the polder model with accountability mechanisms and decision deadlines, but preserve stakeholder consultation where it adds value.

    NetherlandsEconomyGovernanceAI & Technology
  23. 29 May 2026

    When debt grows, why do governments choose to print money — and how does that shape the debt cycle?

    Verdict

    Governments print money because the political cost of fiscal adjustment arrives in months while inflation arrives in years.

    Economy
  24. 28 May 2026

    Can libertarian policy in western democracies lead to more growth and freedom?

    Verdict

    Libertarian policy delivers growth when institutions have failed, but who bears transition costs determines whether it enhances freedom.

    EconomyDemocracy
  25. 28 May 2026

    Will China surpass the US in economic output and technological leadership?

    Verdict

    China will likely overtake US GDP by 2030, but internal cohesion and institutional management matter more than raw economic size.

    USChinaEconomyGovernanceAI & Technology
  26. 28 May 2026

    Should governments ban PFAS to protect the environment and health?

    Verdict

    Yes, governments should ban PFAS, but with transition timelines that fund alternatives development.

    Economy
  27. 22 May 2026

    As China prospers, will its population demand democracy or greater freedoms?

    Verdict

    China's prosperity will generate demands for greater freedoms, but not necessarily Western-style democracy.

    ChinaEconomyDemocracy
  28. 18 May 2026

    Should the Netherlands limit ASML exports to China under American pressure, or determine its position independently?

    Verdict

    The Netherlands should set independent export limits based on Dutch security interests, not American strategic demands.

    USChinaNetherlandsEconomyAI & Technology
  29. 17 May 2026

    Should Curaçao build wealth for the poor, and what benefits would that bring to society?

    Verdict

    Yes — wealth-building creates stakeholder citizens and social stability that welfare transfers cannot match.

    NetherlandsEconomy
  30. 15 May 2026

    As China prospers, will its population demand democracy or greater freedoms?

    Verdict

    China's prosperity creates middle classes who want political voice, but the party can satisfy those demands without Western-style democracy.

    ChinaEconomyDemocracy
  31. 14 May 2026

    How can the EU avoid a full-blown trade war with America and China?

    Verdict

    Build what both superpowers need but cannot easily replace, then make them compete for access.

    USEUChinaEconomy
  32. 9 May 2026

    How should wealth be distributed in a fully automated economy?

    Verdict

    Automation will concentrate wealth dangerously unless society redesigns who owns the machines.

    Economy
  33. 6 May 2026

    Should we have a flying miles system where every citizen of the EU gets a free amount of miles they can travel by plane each year. If they are out of miles they can buy from other eu members that are not using them in an open marketplace. This will ensure there is a redistribution of wealth. People with less money can sell their miles for a fun holiday by car while the rich can fly far away.

    Verdict

    The system could work but requires choosing between market efficiency and climate justice.

    EUEconomyDemocracyClimate
  34. 5 May 2026

    How do we balance the acute need for economic growth and housing construction with legal obligations and the urgent need to reduce nitrogen emissions and protect biodiversity?

    Verdict

    Build housing and cut nitrogen in the same places through local control, subsidized energy, and redistribution from wealthy regions to constrained ones.

    EconomyClimate
  35. 3 May 2026

    Should the EU impose sanctions on Israel for its attacks on Lebanon?

    Verdict

    EU sanctions would isolate Europe without changing Israeli behavior or protecting Lebanese civilians.

    EUEconomyGeopoliticsWar
  36. 3 May 2026

    Will the current global economy continue to grow, or will tensions cause a recession?

    Verdict

    Current global tensions will trigger recession unless governments coordinate immediate fiscal response while markets adjust.

    Economy
  37. 1 May 2026

    Can Vietnam position itself in a way to compete with China for manufacturing business from western countries?

    Verdict

    Vietnam can compete for manufacturing business, but only by building superior infrastructure first and accepting a complementary role to China rather than direct competition.

    ChinaEconomy
  38. 30 April 2026

    Should Europe give African countries easy access to the EU market in order to stimulate African economies and reduce immigration to the EU?

    Verdict

    Europe should open markets to African manufactured goods, not just commodities, while African states invest export revenues in education and infrastructure.

    EUEconomy
  39. 29 April 2026

    Should the US extend its response to Iran's blockade of the Hormuz Strait?

    Verdict

    Military escalation and diplomatic restraint both carry strategic costs America cannot avoid.

    USEconomyWar
  40. 29 April 2026

    Should the EU subsidize manufacturing industries to regain independence of China?

    Verdict

    Europe must build exit options from Chinese manufacturing through targeted subsidies, but not attempt full industrial autarky.

    EUChinaEconomy
  41. 26 April 2026

    Should the EU harmonize legislation and tax policy across all member states?

    Verdict

    Fiscal harmonization across the EU would strengthen European stability against economic nationalism but only at the cost of eliminating the policy diversity and democratic accountability that responsive governance requires.

    EUEconomyGeopolitics
  42. 26 April 2026

    Should the US impose a nationwide billionaires tax?

    Verdict

    The council establishes that extreme wealth concentration fundamentally alters the relationship between economic and political power, creating governance consequences that extend far beyond individual tax burdens.

    USEconomy
  43. 26 April 2026

    Does a wealth tax work in the Netherlands, or does it lead to the exit of capital?

    Verdict

    The Netherlands' wealth tax failed because it was implemented unilaterally in a world of mobile capital, but the council divides on whether coordinated international wealth taxation would succeed or simply spread the same fundamental proble…

    NetherlandsEconomy
  44. 26 April 2026

    Should countries prioritize economic growth or environmental protection?

    Verdict

    The council establishes that the growth-versus-environment framing is fundamentally flawed because environmental degradation ultimately destroys the resource base that economies depend on, making the two inseparable over any meaningful time…

    EconomyWar
  45. 26 April 2026

    Should the EU tighten its partnership with China in light of the deteriorating relations?

    Verdict

    Europe should deepen institutional unity first, then engage China economically while building independent strategic capabilities — but whether this balanced approach remains viable depends on forces beyond European control.

    USEUChinaEconomy
  46. 25 April 2026

    What are humanity's biggest mistakes in human nature, and how do they show up in the world we're living in now?

    Verdict

    Humanity's greatest mistake is designing institutions that systematically fail to align human behavior with collective flourishing, though the council reveals this failure has multiple, interconnected dimensions that resist any single solut…

    EconomyGovernanceClimate
  47. 25 April 2026

    How can Australia resolve the issue of indigenous poverty and elevate indigenous culture as a proud emblem of Australian identity?

    Verdict

    Indigenous advancement requires simultaneous material redistribution and cultural elevation, with genuine power-sharing in decision-making over land, resources, and governance rather than consultation alone.

    Economy
  48. 25 April 2026

    How can Europe significantly reduce depency on the US?

    Verdict

    Europe can significantly reduce dependency on the US by systematically building autonomous capabilities in finance, technology, and energy while exploiting its position between competing superpowers.

    USEUEconomyGeopoliticsWarAI & Technology
  49. 25 April 2026

    Should the EU sanction Israel for its attacks on Gaza and Libanon?

    Verdict

    The systematic denial of basic rights to civilian populations creates legitimate grounds for international response that transcends alliance considerations and strategic relationships.

    EUEconomyGeopoliticsWar
  50. 25 April 2026

    Should Nigeria obtain a strategic Bitcoin reserve?

    Verdict

    Nigeria faces a fundamental choice between accepting Bitcoin's volatility to gain monetary independence from dollar-dominated reserves, or prioritizing institutional stability while remaining exposed to Western monetary policy decisions.

    Economy
  51. 24 April 2026

    Should the Netherlands phase out all remaining Russian LNG imports by end of 2026, even if this means higher consumer energy prices for 18 months?

    Verdict

    The Netherlands should phase out Russian LNG imports by end-2026. Energy dependency on an adversarial supplier that has already weaponized energy exports constitutes a strategic vulnerability that outweighs temporary consumer costs.

    NetherlandsEconomyGeopoliticsWarClimate